NAS 410 vs SNT-TC-1A: What's Different and Which Applies
NAS 410 vs SNT-TC-1A: standard vs recommended practice, who certifies, the Level 3 role, exams, vision, hours, recertification, and which one your work needs.
Short answer: NAS 410 is an aerospace standard with mandatory minimums that apply once a contract invokes it. SNT-TC-1A is ASNT's recommended practice, binding through the employer's written practice. Both are employer-based, with general, specific and practical examinations. Aerospace hardware under a prime's flow-down follows NAS 410 or EN 4179; ASME, API and AWS work follows SNT-TC-1A or CP-189.
Both documents certify NDT personnel by method and level, both put an NDT Level 3 (Level III in ASNT terms) at the center, and both leave the certification in the employer's hands. The differences are in authority, control and the detail of the requirements. This page sets them side by side. For how NAS 410 works on its own, see NAS 410 explained; for the ASNT side, see what SNT-TC-1A is.
A standard versus a recommended practice
NAS 410 is a National Aerospace Standard published by the Aerospace Industries Association (AIA). It is written as requirements. Once a purchase order or a customer's quality clause invokes it, its minimums are contractual and an auditor treats any shortfall as a nonconformance. Revision 6, released in December 2025, is the current revision.
SNT-TC-1A is ASNT's Recommended Practice for the qualification and certification of NDT personnel. The 2024 edition, with its addendum, is current; the 2020 edition came before it. It tells employers what a sound program contains and leaves the binding detail to the employer's written practice, which turns the document's recommendations into the company's own rules. Codes and contracts give it force: ASME, API and AWS documents call for personnel certified to SNT-TC-1A, and some call for ANSI/ASNT CP-189, ASNT's companion document written as a standard with minimum requirements. See SNT-TC-1A vs CP-189 for that distinction.
So the opening question is never which document is better. It is which document your contract names.
NAS 410 vs SNT-TC-1A at a glance
| Topic | NAS 410 | ASNT SNT-TC-1A |
|---|---|---|
| Publisher and current edition | AIA; Revision 6, December 2025 | ASNT; 2024 edition with addendum |
| Status | Standard with mandatory minimums once invoked | Recommended practice; binding through the employer's written practice |
| Who certifies | The employer, under a written practice approved by its Responsible Level 3 | The employer, under a written practice approved by an NDT Level III |
| Levels | Trainee, Level 1 Limited, Level 1, Level 2, Level 3 | Level I, Level II and Level III, with trainees under supervision |
| Level 3 role | A designated Responsible Level 3 holds authority over the whole program; Level 3s are examined within the employer's program | The Level III approves the written practice, procedures and examinations; an ASNT NDT Level III certificate can satisfy the Basic and Method examinations |
| Examinations | General, specific (at least 30 questions) and practical at each level | General, specific and practical for Level I and II; Basic, Method and Specific for Level III |
| Practical examination | Required at every level; the Level 3 practical includes writing a procedure or technique | Hands-on practical for Level I and II on the employer's specimens and procedures |
| Grading | Minimum per examination and minimum average (70% and 80% in the harmonized EN 4179 text) | Recommended composite of at least 80%, with no examination below 70% |
| Vision | Near vision at least every 12 months, plus color perception | Near vision of Jaeger number 2 or equivalent at 12 inches or more, every 12 months, plus color contrast |
| Training and experience | Mandatory minimum hours by method and level; formal, documented courses | Recommended minimum hours by method and level, adopted through the written practice |
| Recertification | At most every five years, by examination | Recommended maximum of five years, by evidence of continuing satisfactory performance or re-examination |
| External boards | National Aerospace NDT Boards are optional; common in Europe, none in the US | No national board; employers and their Level IIIs control the program |
| Typical users | Aerospace manufacturers, their suppliers, special process houses, maintenance organizations, defense contractors | Oil and gas, refining, power, pipelines, structural fabrication, general manufacturing, and aerospace or aviation firms whose customers and manuals call for it |
| Usually audited by | Prime customers and Nadcap (AC7114) | Customers, code inspectors and owner-users' auditors |
Who certifies, and what the Level 3 does
Neither document creates a portable central certificate. Under both, the employer certifies its own people and the certification ends with the employment. The real difference is how much control sits with one named person.
Under NAS 410, the employer designates a Responsible Level 3 (RL3) in writing. The RL3 approves the written practice, training courses and instructors, examinations and examiners, and the use of outside agencies, and answers to customers and Nadcap auditors for the program as a whole. The RL3 may be an employee or a Level 3 provided by an outside agency. In several European countries, outside agencies work under a National Aerospace NDT Board (NANDTB); the US has no such board, so US programs rest on the RL3 and on customer audits.
Under SNT-TC-1A, an NDT Level III approves the written practice, procedures and examinations, and no candidate may be examined by themselves or by a subordinate. An employer without a Level III on staff can engage an outside agency Level III, but the employer still issues the certificate. Customers audit the program against the written practice, not against SNT-TC-1A directly.
Is an ASNT Level III recognized under NAS 410?
Partly. The ASNT NDT Level III is a third-party credential. In NAS 410 programs it has long been credited toward the Level 3 general examination in the method, but it does not make anyone a NAS 410 Level 3: the specific and practical examinations, and certification by the employer, still apply. Under SNT-TC-1A the same certificate satisfies the Level III Basic and Method examinations, leaving the employer's Specific examination. ASNT's other central scheme, ASNT 9712, which replaced ACCP and is built on ISO 9712, is also third-party certification and is not the same thing as either employer scheme.
Examinations and the practical
Both schemes use three kinds of examination. On paper they look alike; the detail differs.
- Specific examination. NAS 410 sets a minimum of 30 questions and expects them to test understanding of the employer's procedures and specifications, not the ability to find a clause. SNT-TC-1A recommends minimum question counts and leaves the content to the written practice.
- Practical examination. Both require hands-on testing of specimens at Level 1 and Level 2. NAS 410 adds a Level 3 practical that includes preparing a procedure or technique.
- Grading. SNT-TC-1A recommends a composite of at least 80%, with no examination below 70%. NAS 410 also sets a per-examination minimum and a minimum average; aviation-authority guidance on the harmonized EN 4179 text gives 70% and 80%, and expects every discontinuity in a practical specimen to be found.
- Who examines. Under NAS 410, examiners are designated by the RL3 and must meet the standard's examiner requirements. Under SNT-TC-1A, a Level III, or a representative the written practice designates, administers and grades the examinations.
Vision, training hours and recertification
Vision. SNT-TC-1A recommends near vision of Jaeger number 2 or equivalent at not less than 12 inches every 12 months, plus a color contrast examination suited to the method. NAS 410 programs also check near vision at least yearly and test color perception. The 2021 EN 4179 text accepts Snellen 20/25 at 16 inches, Tumbling E to ISO 18490, or Jaeger number 1 at 12 inches or more. If you run both schemes in one company, give everyone the stricter test.
Training and experience. SNT-TC-1A publishes recommended minimum hours that the written practice adopts as its own rule. NAS 410 publishes minimums a written practice cannot lower, and expects formal, documented courses with approved outlines and qualified instructors. The widest gap is in the surface methods: NAS 410 calls for more formal training in magnetic particle and penetrant testing than SNT-TC-1A recommends. The SNT-TC-1A figures by method are on our aerospace NDT certification requirements page, and the ASNT eligibility rules are summarized in SNT-TC-1A eligibility.
Recertification. Both schemes cap certification at five years: NAS 410 as a requirement, SNT-TC-1A as a recommended maximum that the written practice confirms or shortens. NAS 410 recertification is by examination, typically the specific and practical for Level 1 and Level 2. SNT-TC-1A lets the written practice recertify on documented evidence of continuing satisfactory performance, by re-examination, or by a mix of the two.
Which one applies to your work?
Read the purchase order, the contract and the code. They decide, and the answer often differs between two jobs in the same building.
- Parts or assemblies for an aerospace prime or its suppliers: the purchase order usually names NAS 410 or EN 4179, often with Nadcap accreditation for the NDT methods.
- Aircraft maintenance in Europe under EASA Part-145: EN 4179, with examinations expected under the general control of a national aerospace NDT board.
- FAA repair stations: the standard named in the repair station's manual and customer contracts. FAA advisory circular AC 65-31B lists NAS 410, ATA Specification 105, SNT-TC-1A, ISO 9712 and others as acceptable.
- Defense aerospace subcontracts: NAS 410 flowed down from the prime, since it replaced MIL-STD-410.
- ASME, API and AWS work (pressure vessels, piping, tanks, structural steel): SNT-TC-1A, or CP-189 where the code or contract names it. Nuclear in-service inspection under ASME Section XI looks to CP-189.
An aerospace program can also be built on SNT-TC-1A where the customer's requirements and manuals allow it; our guide to SNT-TC-1A for aerospace NDT covers how that is done. That is a different thing from meeting NAS 410: an SNT-TC-1A program does not satisfy a NAS 410 requirement, and a NAS 410 requirement cannot be answered with an SNT-TC-1A certificate.
Does an SNT-TC-1A certification count toward NAS 410?
Not automatically. A technician moving from an SNT-TC-1A employer to a NAS 410 employer is qualified and certified again under the new employer's program. What transfers is evidence: documented training with outlines and hours, signed experience logs and past examination records. The RL3 decides how much of it to credit and what gap training, especially in the surface methods, and what examinations are still needed.
Mixing the two schemes is a known source of trouble. An ethics column in ASNT's Materials Evaluation described an outside provider that mixed up SNT-TC-1A and NAS 410, which caused audit failures, and a case where invalid certification records forced a program to start again. Each certification should state the standard it was issued under.
Running both schemes in one company
Companies that serve aerospace and industrial customers face a structural choice: two written practices, or one written practice with separate requirements for each scheme. Either can work if three rules hold:
- Every certification names the standard, and revision, it was issued under.
- Training records are kept to the NAS 410 standard of evidence (approved outlines, qualified instructors, recorded hours) from the start, so they can support either scheme.
- Vision, examinations and recertification follow the stricter rule wherever the two differ, so one person never holds two conflicting records.
Background on written practices under the ASNT model is on our written practice development page, and on aerospace record-keeping in aerospace NDT compliance.
What Atlantis does and doesn't do for NAS 410 programs
Atlantis does not provide NAS 410 training, NAS 410 certification, NAS 410 examinations or a Responsible Level 3. Our founder, Anoop Rayavarapu, holds ASNT NDT Level III certification in UT, RT, MT, PT and VT; he does not hold a Level 3 certification under NAS 410.
For aerospace and aviation companies, the Atlantis offer is the same as for every other sector: ASNT NDT Level III consulting for aerospace (written practices, procedures, examinations, audit preparation and outside agency ASNT Level III services in UT, RT, MT, PT and VT), NDT training based on ASNT SNT-TC-1A, and NDT inspection (UT, MT, PT and VT in the USA; Atlantis does not perform radiography in the USA).
Whether any outside provider's training or examinations can count toward NAS 410 certification is decided by the employer's Responsible Level 3. Ask them before anyone enrolls in a course or books an examination.
NAS 410 vs SNT-TC-1A questions
What is the difference between ASNT and NAS 410?
ASNT publishes SNT-TC-1A, a recommended practice that employers turn into a written practice, and runs third-party certifications such as the ASNT NDT Level III. NAS 410 is AIA's aerospace standard with mandatory minimums, applied through the employer's program and a Responsible Level 3. Both certify people employer by employer; the aerospace standard adds stricter control.
Does SNT-TC-1A satisfy NAS 410?
No. If a purchase order or customer requirement calls for NAS 410, personnel must be certified under a NAS 410 program. An SNT-TC-1A certification can supply evidence the RL3 may credit, but it does not meet the requirement on its own.
Is NAS 410 harder than SNT-TC-1A?
It is more prescriptive. The hours are minimums rather than recommendations, training must be formal and documented, surface-method training is longer, and a Responsible Level 3 controls the whole program. For ultrasonic or radiographic work the day-to-day skills are the same; the evidence behind the certificate is stricter.
Can my SNT-TC-1A Level II transfer to a NAS 410 employer?
Your records can, your certification cannot. Bring your training records, experience logs and examination history. The new employer's RL3 decides what to credit and which training and examinations you still need before you are certified.
Which NDT certification should I choose for aerospace work?
The employer's customers decide, not the technician. US aerospace suppliers commonly certify to NAS 410, European ones to EN 4179, and some aviation and aerospace programs run on SNT-TC-1A where their customers accept it. Strong method training, logged experience and, later, an ASNT NDT Level III help in any of them.
Is "TC 1A" or "210 TC 1A" a separate standard?
No. The ASNT document is Recommended Practice No. SNT-TC-1A. Searches like "210 TC 1A" mix its name with NAS 410. They are two different documents from two different publishers.
Do both standards need a yearly eye test?
Yes. Both expect near vision to be checked at least every 12 months and color vision to be assessed. The acceptance criteria differ, so a company running both schemes should apply the stricter test to everyone.
Where does EN 4179 fit in this comparison?
EN 4179 is the European twin of NAS 410, harmonized with it since the 2000s and current in a 2026 edition. Everything this page says about NAS 410 versus SNT-TC-1A applies broadly to EN 4179 too, except that European programs often run under a national aerospace NDT board.
For the people managing everyone else’s certifications
Tracking one certification is easy; tracking two hundred across five methods, with vision exams, on-the-job hours and client-specific approvals, is where inspection companies lose client audits. Certification tracking and the wider inspection management software guide cover how expiry warnings flag a technician’s certificate before it lapses and how double-booking is blocked at dispatch. There is also a free qualification and calibration register you can start using today.