Is API 1104 the Same as AWS D1.1? Two Codes, Two Kinds of Work
No. API 1104 governs welding of pipelines and related facilities, mainly the girth welds joining line pipe, and requires every welding procedure and welder to be qualified by test under its own rules. AWS D1.1 governs welded structural steel. A welder qualified to D1.1 is not qualified for pipeline work done to API 1104 and has to pass API 1104's own test.
The two codes look alike because both cover arc welding of carbon and low-alloy steel, both require qualified procedures and welders, and both set acceptance standards for the finished weld. They serve different structures and different regulators. API 1104 is written for pipe joined in the field, typically examined by radiography or automated ultrasonics, and US pipeline safety regulations for gas and hazardous liquid lines incorporate it by reference. AWS D1.1 is written for buildings, industrial structures and other welded steel framing, allows prequalified welding procedures that need no procedure test, and relies on visual inspection of every weld with other examinations as the contract specifies. Neither covers the other's work, and neither is the code for refinery process piping or pressure vessels, which belong to the ASME codes and their own qualification rules.
Source: API Standard 1104, Welding of Pipelines and Related Facilities: the current published edition is the 22nd (July 2021), and 49 CFR 192.7 and 195.3 incorporate the 21st edition with its errata and addenda; sections on procedure qualification, welder qualification, inspection and testing of production welds, acceptance standards for nondestructive testing and repair, with the annexes on alternative girth weld acceptance and in-service welding. AWS D1.1/D1.1M:2025, Structural Welding Code - Steel: Clause 5 prequalification, Clause 6 qualification, Clause 8 inspection. 49 CFR Parts 192 and 195.
| Aspect | API 1104 | AWS D1.1 |
|---|---|---|
| Work covered | Pipelines and related facilities: girth, fillet and branch welds on line pipe | Welded structural steel: buildings, industrial and tubular structures |
| Procedure qualification | Every procedure qualified by testing welds | Prequalified procedures allowed within stated limits; others qualified by test |
| Welder qualification | Single or multiple qualification on pipe, tested under API 1104 | Tests by process, position and thickness under D1.1 |
| Typical production NDT | Radiography or automated ultrasonics on girth welds, extent set by the operator and regulation | Visual inspection of all welds; UT, RT, MT or PT where the contract calls for them |
| Acceptance standards | Its own NDT acceptance section; alternative annex criteria where the operator adopts them | Its own criteria, which differ for statically and cyclically loaded connections |
| Who invokes it | Pipeline operators and US pipeline regulations | Building codes, owners and structural engineers through contract documents |
| Not intended for | Refinery process piping and pressure vessels | Pressure vessels and pressure piping |
Is API 1104 the same as AWS D1.1?
No, and the difference matters most to welders and inspectors who move between jobs. The codes cover different structures, qualify people differently and judge welds against different acceptance standards. A qualification record earned under one is not evidence of qualification under the other, and API 1104 requires a welder to pass its test before welding on work it governs, whatever D1.1 qualifications they already hold.
The overlap is real but shallow. Both codes deal with arc welding of carbon and low-alloy steels, both require written procedures, and both start production inspection with visual examination. Beyond that the documents are organised around different problems: API 1104 around the girth weld made in the field, often under schedule pressure, on pipe that will carry pressurised product; AWS D1.1 around connections in steel framing whose loads, fatigue behaviour and geometry are set by a structural engineer.
What each code covers
API 1104 applies to welding of carbon and low-alloy steel pipe used to compress, pump and transport crude oil, petroleum products, fuel gases and similar products, and to related facilities such as compressor and pump stations. It covers new construction and, in an annex, welding on pipelines that are in service. In the United States the federal pipeline safety rules for gas and hazardous liquid lines incorporate it by reference, which is why pipeline operators treat it as mandatory.
AWS D1.1 applies to welded structures made from commonly used carbon and low-alloy constructional steels: buildings, industrial structures, tubular structures and the strengthening or repair of existing structures. It states that it is not intended for pressure vessels or pressure piping, and bridges have their own AWS code, D1.5. Building codes and project specifications bring D1.1 into a contract, and the structural engineer of record decides which of its options apply.
Procedure and welder qualification: why a D1.1 test does not carry over
D1.1 allows prequalified welding procedures: if the joint, process, filler metal, base metal and parameters stay within the code's prequalified limits, the procedure needs no qualification test. API 1104 has no equivalent. Every procedure is qualified by welding test joints and passing the destructive tests the code specifies, and a change in an essential variable, such as the base material, wall thickness range or joint design, requires a new qualification.
Welder qualification follows the same split. API 1104 qualifies welders on pipe, either for a single procedure or, through a more demanding multiple-qualification test, for a range of work, and the test welds are evaluated by destructive testing or by radiography as the code allows. D1.1 qualifies welders by process, position and thickness on plate or pipe coupons. A welder holding D1.1 qualifications in every position still has to take the API 1104 test before welding on a pipeline governed by it.
How production welds are inspected under each code
On a pipeline the girth welds are normally examined by radiography or by automated ultrasonic testing, with the extent set by the operator's specification and, in the US, by the federal rules for the line. API 1104 then supplies the acceptance standards for each type of indication, and an annex offers alternative acceptance standards based on fitness-for-purpose analysis, which an operator can adopt with the supporting qualification work. Repairs are made to a repair procedure and re-examined.
Under D1.1 every weld is visually inspected, and the contract documents decide which welds also receive ultrasonic, radiographic, magnetic particle or penetrant examination. Acceptance criteria differ for statically and cyclically loaded connections, and the code's ultrasonic acceptance tables use an indication rating in decibels rather than a length-and-depth approach. Under both codes NDT personnel are qualified through a recognised scheme, in US practice normally the employer's written practice to SNT-TC-1A.
Which code applies to your job
Ask what is being built and who regulates it. Line pipe and the welds that join it in a transmission, gathering or distribution system point to API 1104, often alongside ASME B31.4 or B31.8 for design. Steel framing, platforms, supports and structural members point to D1.1. Station piping inside a compressor or pump station follows whatever the operator's specification names, commonly API 1104 or ASME Section IX for qualification. Pipe racks that carry process piping are D1.1 structures, while the process piping on them follows ASME B31.3.
Outside the United States the answer still starts with the regulator and the operator's specification. In Canada, oil and gas pipeline systems are governed by CSA Z662, which carries its own welding and inspection requirements, so a welder or inspector moving north checks which standard the operator has named before assuming API 1104 applies. Structural work in Canada is commonly done to CSA W59 rather than D1.1, for the same reason.
Common mistakes
Sending a D1.1-qualified welder to a pipeline job without an API 1104 test. Using a D1.1 prequalified procedure on line pipe. Applying D1.1 visual criteria to a girth weld, or API 1104 criteria to a structural connection. Letting an NDT technician interpret pipeline radiographs against the wrong code's acceptance table because both are welding codes. Treating an old test record as proof of current qualification when the code's continuity or requalification rules have lapsed. Assuming either code covers ASME pressure piping.
For welders and inspectors working across both
Keep separate records of qualification under each code, with the procedure, test date and continuity evidence for each, and study the acceptance standards of the code you are about to work to, not the one you know best. For inspectors, visual weld examination to a written procedure is the common ground, and VT Level 2 training builds it. Girth weld interpretation is covered in the API 1104 acceptance criteria guide, and the API 1104 summary and AWS D1.1 summary set out each code's scope.
Does an AWS D1.1 welder certification qualify me for API 1104 pipeline work?
No. API 1104 requires welders to pass its own qualification test on pipe, under a qualified API 1104 procedure, before welding on work it governs. A D1.1 record shows skill, but it is not an API 1104 qualification.
Does API 1104 allow prequalified welding procedures?
No. Every API 1104 welding procedure is qualified by welding test joints and passing the code's destructive tests. Prequalified procedures are a feature of AWS D1.1 and do not carry over to pipeline work.
Which code sets pipeline girth weld radiography acceptance?
API 1104, in its acceptance standards for nondestructive testing, unless the operator adopts the alternative acceptance standards in its annex, which need additional qualification work. AWS D1.1 radiographic criteria do not apply to pipeline girth welds.
Is API 1104 used for structural steel?
No. API 1104 is written for pipelines and related facilities. Structural steel framing, including pipe racks and pipe supports, is normally welded and inspected to AWS D1.1.
Do US pipeline regulations require API 1104?
The federal pipeline safety rules in 49 CFR Parts 192 and 195 incorporate API 1104 by reference for welding and its acceptance standards, so operators apply it to regulated gas and hazardous liquid lines. Check which edition the regulation names, because it can lag the latest published edition.
Does AWS D1.1 apply to pressure piping?
No. D1.1 states that it is not intended for pressure vessels or pressure piping. Process piping follows ASME B31.3, power piping ASME B31.1, and pressure vessels the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code.
Need this applied on your job?
Atlantis writes and reviews procedures to this code, inspects welds against it, and trains technicians in visual weld inspection.
Welding procedures and the NDT that follows them
A WPS tells the welder how to weld; an NDT procedure tells the technician how to examine the result. These pages explain both and where they meet.
Next step: VT Level 2 course
API 1104 or AWS D1.1 work is checked first by visual examination of the finished welds. The VT Level 2 course covers weld and surface visual examination, measurement with weld gauges, and accept or reject decisions against the governing acceptance criteria. Completing a course is not certification: under an employer-based scheme such as SNT-TC-1A, your employer certifies you after its own examinations.
For employers: ASNT Level III consulting covers procedures, the written practice, qualification examinations and audit support for your technicians.