{"id":"1378","title":"WPS, PQR and WPQ Explained: ASME IX, AWS D1.1, API 1104","slug":"wps-pqr-wpq-explained-asme-ix-aws-d1-1-api-1104","author":"Atlantis NDT","category":"Codes and Standards","metaDescription":"What a WPS, PQR and welder qualification record are, who signs them, the tests behind each, and how ASME IX, AWS D1.1 and API 1104 differ, incl. NDT rules.","snippet":"What a WPS, PQR and welder qualification record are, who signs them, the tests behind each, and how ASME IX, AWS D1.1 and API 1104 differ, incl. NDT rules.","content":"<p><strong>Short answer:</strong> A WPS tells the welder how to make a weld. A PQR proves, with a test weld and laboratory results, that the procedure produces sound joints. A WPQ (often called a WPQR) proves that one particular welder can follow it. The fabricator qualifies and signs all three, and the inspector verifies them before production starts.</p>\n\n<h2>What are a WPS, a PQR and a WPQ?</h2>\n<p>Three records travel together in every welding dossier. Each answers a different question, and mixing them up causes most welding audit findings.</p>\n<ul>\n<li><strong>WPS (welding procedure specification):</strong> the written instruction for the shop floor. It gives ranges, not single values: process, base metal grouping, filler metal, thickness and diameter range, joint design, preheat and interpass temperature, electrical settings, shielding gas, technique and postweld heat treatment (PWHT).</li>\n<li><strong>PQR (procedure qualification record):</strong> what was actually done on a test coupon, as welded, plus the test results. It records facts, not ranges. Clerical errors can be corrected; the test is never rewritten to suit production.</li>\n<li><strong>WPQ or WPQR (welder performance qualification record):</strong> one welder&apos;s test: the WPS followed, the variables used, the results and the range of work now qualified. ASME Section IX calls it a WPQ and provides a suggested form, QW-484A. AWS D1.1 shops usually say WPQR.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>A terminology trap for international projects: under ISO 15614, &quot;WPQR&quot; means welding procedure qualification record, the ISO counterpart of a PQR, not a welder record.</p>\n<table>\n<thead><tr><th>Record</th><th>Prepared and certified by</th><th>Verified by</th><th>Changes allowed</th></tr></thead>\n<tbody>\n<tr><td>WPS</td><td>The organization that does the welding: manufacturer, fabricator or contractor</td><td>Authorized Inspector, the Engineer&apos;s or owner&apos;s inspector, or the pipeline company, depending on the code</td><td>Nonessential variables by documented revision; an essential variable change needs a new or additional PQR</td></tr>\n<tr><td>PQR</td><td>The same organization, which certifies the values are a true record of the test</td><td>The same reviewers</td><td>Clerical corrections to the record; the test stands as welded</td></tr>\n<tr><td>WPQ / WPQR</td><td>The welder&apos;s employer, which conducts and certifies the test</td><td>The inspector, before production welding</td><td>A new test to widen the range; continuity keeps it in force</td></tr>\n</tbody>\n</table>\n<p>ASME Section IX states the principle in QG-106: the organization doing the welding is responsible for qualifying its own procedures and welders, and it must supervise and control the qualification work. Section IX also lets an organization adopt AWS Standard Welding Procedure Specifications listed in its Appendix E, under Article V, instead of running its own procedure test. AWS D1.1 places the same duty on the Contractor. On regulated US pipelines, 49 CFR 192.225(b) requires each welding procedure to be recorded in detail with its qualifying test results, retained, and followed whenever it is used.</p>\n<p>Atlantis NDT does not write, sign or qualify welding procedures, and it does not act as inspector of record. Our side is the examination: NDT of welds and test coupons, NDT procedures written by an ASNT NDT Level III, and NDT technician training.</p>\n\n<h2>The life cycle: from preliminary WPS to production</h2>\n<ol>\n<li><strong>Preliminary WPS.</strong> The welding engineer drafts intended variables from the code, material, joint and service.</li>\n<li><strong>Test weld.</strong> A coupon is welded under control, recording actual amperage, voltage, travel speed, preheat, interpass temperature, gas flow and filler.</li>\n<li><strong>Testing.</strong> Visual examination, NDT where the code requires it, then laboratory tension, bend and, where required, impact or macroetch tests.</li>\n<li><strong>PQR certified.</strong> The organization signs that the record reflects the test and that the results met the code.</li>\n<li><strong>WPS written.</strong> The WPS takes the ranges the code allows from the tested values. One PQR can support several WPSs, and a WPS can cite more than one PQR.</li>\n<li><strong>Welder qualification.</strong> Each welder passes a test, often on the procedure coupon itself, and receives a WPQ stating the qualified range.</li>\n<li><strong>Production.</strong> The WPS is at the work station, welders work inside their ranges, and the inspector checks both.</li>\n<li><strong>Continuity.</strong> Under Section IX (QW-322) and AWS D1.1, a welder&apos;s qualification for a process lapses after six months without using it. A dated continuity log proves it never lapsed.</li>\n</ol>\n<p>Editions add one more step. The 2025 edition of Section IX became mandatory for new qualifications on January 1, 2026. Earlier qualifications stay valid, but under QG-108, when an older PQR supports a WPS updated to the current edition, every current essential variable (and supplementary essential variable, for toughness work) must be recorded on that PQR.</p>\n\n<h2>Essential, supplementary essential and nonessential variables</h2>\n<p>Section IX classifies each procedure variable, process by process, in the QW-250 tables (QW-253 covers shielded metal arc welding). The class decides what a change means.</p>\n<h3>Essential variables</h3>\n<p>Changes that affect the joint&apos;s mechanical properties and force requalification with a new or additional PQR. Examples: changing the welding process; a base metal P-Number the PQR does not cover; a different filler metal F-Number; adding or deleting PWHT; cutting preheat by more than 100&#xB0;F (55&#xB0;C) below the qualified value; thickness outside the coupon&apos;s qualified range.</p>\n<h3>Supplementary essential variables</h3>\n<p>These apply when the referencing construction code requires notch toughness (impact) testing, for example in low-temperature service. They then act as essential variables, and the PQR must include Charpy V-notch results. Examples: a base metal Group Number change within a P-Number, higher heat input than qualified, and a maximum interpass temperature raised more than 100&#xB0;F. The 2025 edition added QW-410.92, which changes how travel speed is measured for heat input on weave beads wider than 1 in. The 2019 edition removed the vertical-uphill position variable.</p>\n<h3>Nonessential variables</h3>\n<p>Changes that need no new test, though the WPS must be revised and the revision recorded: groove design details, backing for the procedure, cleaning method, and electrode size within the process rules.</p>\n<p>Welders have their own variable list. Position is an essential variable for the welder, while adding a position is a nonessential procedure change. Backing works the same way: deleting it is nonessential for a procedure, but a welder who tested with backing is qualified to weld with backing, while a welder who tested without it is qualified for both.</p>\n<p>AWS D1.1 and API 1104 use the same idea with their own lists. API 1104&apos;s procedure variables include items such as pipe grade grouping, joint design, position, wall thickness group, filler metal group, time between passes, direction of welding, and shielding gas and flow rate; the 21st edition sets more than 20% change in nominal gas flow as the threshold.</p>\n\n<h2>Prequalified WPSs under AWS D1.1</h2>\n<p>AWS D1.1/D1.1M:2025, the Structural Welding Code for steel, lets a fabricator use a WPS without a procedure test when every element stays inside Clause 5: a prequalified process, listed base metals with matching filler metals, prequalified joint details, the code&apos;s minimum preheat and interpass temperatures, and its electrical and bead-size limits. The prequalified processes include SMAW, SAW, FCAW and GMAW other than short-circuit transfer. Step outside any limit and the WPS must be qualified by test under Clause 6.</p>\n<ul>\n<li>A prequalified WPS must still be written. Prequalification removes the procedure test, not the document, and welders still need their own qualification.</li>\n<li>When the contract calls for Charpy toughness in the weld, prequalification does not satisfy it.</li>\n<li>The 2025 edition split the prequalified WPS requirements table by process and added minimum current and maximum layer width limits, so recheck WPSs written against the 2020 tables.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>Section IX has no prequalified category; the nearest equivalent is adopting an AWS standard WPS under Article V. API 1104 requires every procedure to be qualified by test.</p>\n\n<h2>How ASME IX, AWS D1.1 and API 1104 differ</h2>\n<table>\n<thead><tr><th>Topic</th><th>ASME Section IX</th><th>AWS D1.1</th><th>API 1104</th></tr></thead>\n<tbody>\n<tr><td>Current edition</td><td>2025 edition; mandatory for new qualifications from January 1, 2026</td><td>D1.1/D1.1M:2025, with Amendment 1</td><td>22nd edition (July 2021), Errata 1 (2023); 49 CFR 192 and 195 incorporate the 21st edition</td></tr>\n<tr><td>What it is</td><td>A qualification standard invoked by ASME construction codes such as Section VIII and B31.3</td><td>A full code for welded structural steel</td><td>Pipelines and related facilities, mainly field girth welds</td></tr>\n<tr><td>Prequalified WPS</td><td>No; AWS standard WPSs can be adopted under Article V</td><td>Yes, under Clause 5</td><td>No; every procedure is tested</td></tr>\n<tr><td>Procedure tests</td><td>Tension and guided bend; impact when the construction code requires; no NDT required on the coupon</td><td>Visual, then RT or UT of a CJP groove coupon, then tension and bend specimens; macroetch for fillet and PJP; impact when the contract requires</td><td>Tensile, nick-break and bend specimens</td></tr>\n<tr><td>Welder tests</td><td>Bend tests, or volumetric NDE (RT or UT) under QW-191</td><td>Bend tests; radiography may be used instead for most processes, not short-circuit GMAW</td><td>Destructive tests, or radiography or automated UT at the company&apos;s option</td></tr>\n<tr><td>Continuity</td><td>Six months per process (QW-322)</td><td>Six months per process</td><td>Code rules plus 49 CFR 192.229 on regulated gas lines</td></tr>\n<tr><td>Production acceptance</td><td>Set by the construction code, not Section IX</td><td>Set in the code&apos;s inspection clause</td><td>Set in its own NDT acceptance section</td></tr>\n</tbody>\n</table>\n<p>More detail: <a href=\"/standards/asme-section-ix\">ASME Section IX reference</a>, <a href=\"/standards/api-1104-vs-aws-d1-1\">API 1104 vs AWS D1.1</a> and <a href=\"/blog/aws-d1-1-vs-asme-ix-welder-qualification-2026-decoded\">AWS D1.1 vs ASME IX welder qualification</a>.</p>\n\n<h2>What tests does a PQR need?</h2>\n<p><strong>ASME Section IX.</strong> A groove weld procedure coupon gives two tension specimens (QW-150) and four guided-bend specimens (QW-160): side bends for coupons 3/4 in. and thicker, normally face and root bends below that. Tension passes at the base metal&apos;s specified minimum tensile strength, or 95% of it when the break is in base metal away from the weld (QW-153). A bend fails with an open discontinuity over 1/8 in. in the weld or heat-affected zone on the convex surface (QW-163). Notch toughness specimens (QW-170) are added when the construction code requires them. Coupon thickness sets the range: a 1 in. groove coupon qualifies base metal from 3/16 in. through 2 in. Section IX does not require NDT of a procedure coupon.</p>\n<p><strong>AWS D1.1.</strong> A complete joint penetration (CJP) groove coupon is visually examined and then radiographed or ultrasonically examined before specimens are cut; unacceptable internal flaws reject it. Plate over 3/8 in. then gives two reduced-section tension specimens and four side bends. Partial penetration and fillet qualifications include macroetch tests, and Charpy tests are added when the contract calls for them.</p>\n<p><strong>API 1104.</strong> Procedure welds are evaluated by tensile, nick-break and bend specimens, the number set by pipe diameter and wall thickness. A nick-break specimen is broken through the weld so the fracture face can be checked for porosity, slag and lack of fusion. See the <a href=\"/standards/api-1104\">API 1104 overview</a>.</p>\n\n<h2>Welder qualification tests, and when NDT can replace bend tests</h2>\n<p>Every code starts with visual examination of the welder&apos;s coupon; the rules for replacing bend tests with volumetric examination differ sharply.</p>\n<h3>ASME Section IX</h3>\n<p>QW-302 allows a welder&apos;s groove weld coupon to be evaluated by bend tests or by volumetric NDE, radiography or ultrasonic examination, under QW-191. QW-304 lists the processes that may use the volumetric route, including SMAW, SAW, GTAW, PAW and GMAW. The conditions:</p>\n<ul>\n<li>Radiography may not be used for GMAW in short-circuit transfer. The exclusion is written for radiography, so ultrasonic examination under QW-191 remains open to those welders on a thick enough coupon.</li>\n<li>Ultrasonic examination is allowed on coupons down to 1/4 in. (6 mm) thick; before the 2017 edition the floor was 1/2 in. Thinner coupons go to bend tests or radiography.</li>\n<li>Coverage is at least 6 in. (150 mm) of weld on a plate coupon and the full circumference of a pipe coupon.</li>\n<li>The coupon is judged against the acceptance criteria in QW-191, not the production code&apos;s.</li>\n<li>The examination follows a written procedure meeting Section V, by an examiner certified under the employer&apos;s written practice. The 2025 edition (QW-191.4) accepts certification to the SNT-TC-1A edition in use on the project, an earlier edition, or another NDE personnel standard in use on the project.</li>\n<li>Some nonferrous metal groups are excluded or limited, so check QW-304 before planning aluminum or titanium tests.</li>\n</ul>\n<h3>AWS D1.1</h3>\n<p>Welder coupons are visually examined and then bend tested. Radiography may replace the bend tests for most processes; short-circuit GMAW is excluded.</p>\n<h3>API 1104</h3>\n<p>The welder&apos;s test weld is visually examined and then destructively tested. In the 21st edition the company may instead have the qualification butt weld examined by radiography or automated ultrasonic testing under a qualified NDT procedure. On regulated gas lines, 49 CFR 192.229 bars a welder qualified by nondestructive testing alone from welding compressor station pipe and components.</p>\n<h3>Radiography in the United States</h3>\n<p>Atlantis NDT does not perform radiography in the USA. Where Section IX allows ultrasonic examination of a welder coupon, our <a href=\"/ultrasonic-weld-inspection\">ultrasonic weld inspection</a> technicians can examine it to a written procedure. Where the code or contract requires radiography, the fabricator&apos;s or owner&apos;s licensed radiography contractor performs it, and an ASNT Level III can review the images. A free template for recording the test is on the <a href=\"/resources/welder-qualification-test-wpqr\">welder qualification test record (WPQR) page</a>.</p>\n\n<h2>WPS vs NDT procedure: two different documents</h2>\n<p>Both are called procedures and both appear in the same audit, but they answer to different codes and different signatures.</p>\n<table>\n<thead><tr><th>Question</th><th>Welding procedure (WPS)</th><th>NDT procedure</th></tr></thead>\n<tbody>\n<tr><td>What it tells you</td><td>How the welder makes the weld</td><td>How the technician examines the weld</td></tr>\n<tr><td>Governing documents</td><td>ASME Section IX, AWS D1.1 or API 1104</td><td>ASME Section V (Article 4 weld UT, Article 6 PT, Article 7 MT, Article 9 VT) or the NDT clauses of D1.1 and API 1104</td></tr>\n<tr><td>Who approves it</td><td>The fabricator, which certifies the supporting PQR</td><td>An NDT Level III under the employer&apos;s written practice to ASNT SNT-TC-1A or CP-189</td></tr>\n<tr><td>How it is proven</td><td>Destructive tests on a welded coupon, recorded on a PQR</td><td>Demonstration to the Inspector when the referencing code requires it, and qualification on a specimen with known flaws where a code demands that</td></tr>\n<tr><td>Who uses it</td><td>A welder with a current WPQ</td><td>A technician certified for the method and level</td></tr>\n</tbody>\n</table>\n<p>&quot;PQR&quot; appears on both sides. An NDT procedure qualification record documents an examination procedure finding known flaws in a test block; it has nothing to do with a welding PQR. Our <a href=\"/consulting/ndt-procedure-qualification-demonstration\">procedure qualification and demonstration</a> service covers the NDT version, and <a href=\"/consulting/ndt-technical-procedure-development\">NDT procedure development</a> writes the examination procedures. Neither produces a WPS.</p>\n\n<h2>What an inspector checks on site against the WPS</h2>\n<ul>\n<li><strong>Documents:</strong> the WPS is at the work station, current, on the contract&apos;s code edition, and supported by its cited PQRs.</li>\n<li><strong>Welder:</strong> a WPQ covering the process, position, diameter, thickness, filler group and backing condition, with a current continuity log.</li>\n<li><strong>Materials:</strong> base metal and filler classification match the WPS; low-hydrogen electrodes are stored as required.</li>\n<li><strong>Fit-up:</strong> groove angle, root opening, root face, backing, alignment and cleanliness.</li>\n<li><strong>Welding:</strong> preheat and interpass measured at the right location; amperage, voltage, polarity and travel speed, with heat input calculated where it is a supplementary essential variable; gas type and flow; bead width; interpass cleaning.</li>\n<li><strong>Afterwards:</strong> PWHT charts where required, visual examination of every weld, the NDT the construction code calls for, and a weld map tying each joint to its welder and WPS.</li>\n</ul>\n\n<h2>Common mistakes auditors find</h2>\n<ul>\n<li><strong>Ranges outside the PQR:</strong> thickness or material coverage the coupon never earned.</li>\n<li><strong>Toughness service without support:</strong> a low-temperature WPS on a PQR with no impact data.</li>\n<li><strong>Edited PQRs:</strong> test values changed to match production settings.</li>\n<li><strong>Expired continuity:</strong> a welder card on file with no dated use of the process in the last six months.</li>\n<li><strong>Welder outside range:</strong> a position, diameter or backing condition the WPQ does not cover.</li>\n<li><strong>Wrong code edition:</strong> a WPS moved to a newer Section IX edition without updating the PQR&apos;s recorded variables; D1.1 2020 tables on a 2025 contract; an API 1104 22nd edition qualification where the regulation cites the 21st.</li>\n<li><strong>Misused rules:</strong> a &quot;prequalified&quot; D1.1 WPS for short-circuit GMAW, a GMAW-S welder qualified by radiography under Section IX, or a UT-examined coupon thinner than 1/4 in.</li>\n<li><strong>Missing evidence:</strong> no laboratory report, NDT report or signature behind the record.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>A shorter guide to keeping these records apart: <a href=\"/blog/asme-section-ix-wps-pqr-welder-qualification-2026-decoded\">WPS, PQR and welder qualification: keeping the records separate</a>.</p>\n\n<h2>Where NDT fits in production welding</h2>\n<p>Section IX qualifies procedures and people; it does not decide whether a production weld is acceptable. The construction code sets the extent of examination and the acceptance criteria. Section VIII Division 1 covers radiography in UW-51 and UW-52 and other methods in mandatory appendices. ASME B31.3 sets weld acceptance in Table 341.3.2, AWS D1.1 in its inspection clause, and API 1104 in its NDT acceptance section.</p>\n<p>Most US weld jobs use four methods: visual testing of every weld; <a href=\"/magnetic-particle-weld-inspection\">magnetic particle weld inspection</a> for surface and near-surface cracks in ferritic steel; <a href=\"/penetrant-testing-welds\">penetrant testing of welds</a> for surface-breaking flaws in any nonporous metal, including stainless steel; and ultrasonic testing for lack of fusion, incomplete penetration and cracks inside groove welds.</p>\n<p>Atlantis NDT performs UT, MT, PT and VT of welds across the USA, working remotely from Houston and on site when an examination needs it; see our <a href=\"/weld-inspection\">weld inspection services</a>. Our ASNT Level III reviews procedures and reports through <a href=\"/consulting/ndt-consulting-level-iii\">ASNT NDT Level III consulting</a>, and technicians can start with <a href=\"/ndt-level-2-training\">NDT Level 2 training</a> based on SNT-TC-1A, with certification by their employer. To discuss a scope, <a href=\"/contact\">contact us</a>; we reply within one business day.</p>\n\n<h2>Frequently asked questions</h2>\n<h3>What is the difference between a WPS and a PQR?</h3>\n<p>The PQR records what was done on a test coupon and the test results. The WPS is the production instruction, with the ranges the PQR and the code allow. Welders work from the WPS; auditors check that the PQR supports it.</p>\n<h3>Who signs a WPS and a PQR?</h3>\n<p>The organization that does the welding: the manufacturer, fabricator or contractor, which certifies that the PQR is a true record of the test. The Authorized Inspector, the Engineer&apos;s inspector or the pipeline company reviews them, depending on the code.</p>\n<h3>How long does a welder qualification last?</h3>\n<p>Under ASME Section IX and AWS D1.1, as long as the welder uses the process at least every six months, shown by a continuity record. It can be revoked when there is a specific reason to question the welder&apos;s ability. Regulated US pipelines add 49 CFR 192.229.</p>\n<h3>Can ultrasonic testing replace bend tests for welder qualification?</h3>\n<p>Under ASME Section IX, yes, for groove welds made with the processes in QW-304 on coupons at least 1/4 in. (6 mm) thick, judged to QW-191. Under API 1104, the company may choose automated ultrasonic testing. Under AWS D1.1, plan on bend tests or radiography unless your contract&apos;s edition says otherwise.</p>\n<h3>What is the welder qualification range under API 1104?</h3>\n<p>A single qualification covers the variables tested. Requalification is triggered by changes such as welding process, direction of welding, filler metal group, diameter group, wall thickness group, position and joint design. A multiple qualification adds a branch connection test and covers a wider range.</p>\n<h3>Can an AWS D1.1 prequalified WPS be used on ASME work?</h3>\n<p>No. Section IX has no prequalified category. ASME work needs a WPS supported by a PQR, or an AWS Standard Welding Procedure Specification adopted under Section IX Article V.</p>\n<h3>Does Atlantis NDT write or qualify welding procedures?</h3>\n<p>No. Atlantis does not write, sign or qualify WPSs or PQRs. We perform UT, MT, PT and VT of welds and test coupons in the USA, write and qualify NDT procedures, and train NDT technicians. Your welding engineer or fabricator owns the welding procedures.</p>\n","updatedAt":"2026-11-17"}